project_doot_pull_punch_list.md


1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36

---
name: project-doot-pull-punch-list
description: "doot's pull-based punch list (committed_date) shipped 2026-09-03; carry-over is the open design question — ask Peter about it on/after ~2026-09-10 if he hasn't raised it"
metadata: 
  node_type: memory
  type: project
  originSessionId: dc4bccb0-7454-412c-9fcd-f9e336f62a74
  modified: 2026-09-03T07:47:34.540Z
---

Reworked doot's task model so the day's list can actually reach zero. `due_date`
had meant both "real deadline" and "when I plan to do it"; chains stamped
`due_date = now` on every unlock, so milestones arrived looking overdue. Split
into `due_date` (deadlines only) + `committed_date` ("I chose this for today").
The day = committed work + genuine deadlines; chain steps and bucket items reach
it only via a "+ today" pull. Shipped and verified against production 2026-09-03.
Full design and remaining gaps live in the repo at
`docs/superpowers/specs/2026-09-02-pull-based-punch-list-design.md` — read that
rather than restating it here.

**Open question — carry-over.** A task committed today and not finished simply
stops appearing tomorrow; it does not show as carried. The choice (auto-roll
forward vs. make him re-choose it during a review) is about how Peter wants to
work, not something to infer.

**Why:** He explicitly said he'd report back after living with it, and: "I'll let
you know about the carryover thing (or if it's been a week or so feel free to
ask)."

**How to apply:** If a doot session happens on or after roughly **2026-09-10** and
he hasn't raised carry-over, ask him directly — a short question about which
behavior he wants, not a proposal to build both. Don't build carry-over before
that answer. Related: [[feedback_investigate_the_actual_claim]] and
[[feedback_user_does_not_read_code]] — this is exactly the class of question to
ask about *intent* rather than infer from symptoms, which is what went wrong
mid-session on the recurrence fix.