1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
|
---
name: feedback-commit-as-default
description: "On the doot project, commit completed work as a normal part of finishing it -- don't wait for an explicit per-instance ask to commit"
metadata:
node_type: memory
type: feedback
originSessionId: 2607e018-d4ad-4ec6-bb68-5f1d0f9a3906
---
**Commit finished, verified work without waiting to be asked each time.** The global harness default is "never commit unless explicitly asked" -- the user overrode that for this project on 2026-08-04: "committing shouldn't be something I have to ask explicitly for, it should be part of the process." Treat "the fix is done and verified" as sufficient trigger to commit it, the way a competent engineer commits their own completed work without narrating a request for permission each time.
**Why:** Said directly, sharply, after a session where a real production fix sat uncommitted at the end of a long incident-response conversation and the user had to explicitly say "commit your damn work." The friction of re-asking every single time is exactly what they're rejecting.
**How to apply:**
- Once a change is built, tested, and (for this project) deployed/live-verified, commit it as the natural last step -- don't present "done" and wait for a commit request.
- Still use judgment on commit boundaries: split unrelated concerns into separate commits (e.g. a Go server fix vs. an Android app fix are different deploy targets/concerns -- kept as two commits in the 2026-08-04 incident response), and write real commit messages explaining why, not just what.
- This does NOT mean commit everything sitting in the tree indiscriminately -- unrelated in-progress/uncertain work (e.g. a stashed WIP feature from a prior session) should stay uncommitted until its own owner is confident it's done; committing someone's half-finished experiment because "commit by default" is a misapplication of this rule. Ask if genuinely unsure whether something is finished vs. still WIP.
- The global git-safety rules (never force-push, never skip hooks, never amend without being asked, review staged content for secrets before committing) still apply in full -- this override is specifically about the "ask before every commit" gate, not about commit safety practices generally.
- Related: [[feedback-verify-before-asserting-root-cause]] -- both pieces of feedback landed in the same session, both about closing the gap between "looks done" and "is actually, verifiably done."
|
